Carlito T-Shirt
you must win the Challenge Mode Amateur trophy.

Hardcore Championship Belt
you must win the Challenge Mode Legend trophy.

The Million Dollar Championship Belt
You must win the Challenge Mode Legend trophy.

Batista Figure
You must win the 100 Wins trophy.

The Rock
You must complete the Smackdown Storyline.

Steve Austin
You must finish the Raw Storyline.

Cena Baseball Jersey
You must acquire the Rising Star Trophy.

Sledgehammer
You must win the Bar Brawl trophy.

Tiger Skin Rug
You must win the Undertaker Urn trophy.

Jimmy Hart Megaphone
You must unlock Jimmy Hart.